![]() What does it take to cultivate and apply the scout mindset? Julia Galef breaks this down into 4 main sections in the book, with specific concepts and tools for each section. How to Develop and Thrive with the Scout Mindset The earlier you develop an accurate map of the world, the faster you can take effective action to achieve the outcomes you want. This allows us to better evaluate risks, see a wider range of opportunities, understand issues more deeply and address problems effectively. On the other hand, the scout mindset helps us to see things more clearly and objectively. We need to keep rationalizing or denying new information to sustain our belief, thus deepening our self-delusion. Unfortunately, we also end up sacrificing sound judgment or accuracy to make poor decisions that we may regret in future. You can learn more about each of these benefits in our complete summary bundle (which includes a 16-page pdf, an infographic pdf and an audio mp3 of The Scout Mindset summary). Specifically, the soldier’s mindset serves 3 emotional benefits (comfort, self-esteem, and morale), and 3 social benefits (persuasion, image and belonging). Julia Galef suggests that we intuitively adopt the soldier mindset because it’s instantly gratifying. In reality, no one adopts a 100% scout or soldier mindset, and we switch regularly between the 2 mindsets. The scout and soldier mindsets are merely archetypes. ![]() We ask, “is this true?” with a genuine desire to uncover the truth. ![]() We’re driven by accuracy motivated reasoning. When you uncover mistakes or inaccuracies, it gives you a chance to improve your map. At the same time, you know that a map is only a rough estimation of reality, so there’ll always be missing details or errors. The goal is to be as accurate as possible. If we want to accept something we ask, “ Can I believe it?” If we want to reject something we ask, “ Must I believe it? This is also known as the confirmation bias, denial, delusion, self-justification or rationalization. Even if we start out with good intentions to find an answer/solution, we end up trying to prove that we’re right. we decide what to believe based on our underlying motivation. We’re driven by directionally motivated reasoning, i.e. Changing your mind feels like surrendering or being defeated. We focus on fortifying our case and shooting down the other party’s points. We may think that we’re being objective when we’re subconsciously defending our views and beliefs. The soldier mindset is like defensive combat. In a nutshell, there are 2 ways of thinking: the soldier mindset and the scout mindset: 2 ARCHETYPAL WAYS OF THINKING: Scout vs Soldier In this book, she explains how we can use the scout mindset and tools to see things as they are instead of how we want/expect them to be. The question is, when do we succumb to flawed thinking and when do we rise above them? What can we learn from our own successes and how can we multiply what works?įor years, Julia Galef searched for answers to these questions. Yet, we can also acknowledge our flaws and errors, embrace change and be truthful with ourselves. Human beings often deny our mistakes and resist change. Unfortunately, understanding blind spots and biases won’t make you immune to them. There are now lots of research and books about human irrationality and cognitive biases. Do check out our book summary bundle in pdf/mp3 infographic, text and audio formats! In The Scout Mindset summary, you’ll learn how to develop a set of attitude and tools to see the world with more openness, curiosity and accuracy. In this book, Julia Galef explains why it’s so hard to overcome our cognitive biases and how we can learn to see the world more clearly. By default, a truth-seeking mindset generally doesn’t fill those functions, so if we’d like to get people to adopt the “scout mindset,” we’ve got to address those needs head-on.Everyone suffers from mental biases and blind spots. Instead, Julia recognizes that motivated reasoning fulfills important emotional and social functions. Writing about rationality often imagines that if only we could just explain people’s biases to them and show them some Bayesian reasoning, they’d start thinking clearly. But what really interests me about Julia’s approach is that she focuses on the root causes of motivated reasoning as emotional/attitudinal, rather than cognitive. I expected this to mostly be a distillation of CFAR/ LessWrong-style ideas for a pop audience-which it does do, and which is great. Julia Galef’s first book, about the differences between motivated reasoning (“soldier mindset”) and truth-seeking (“scout mindset”), and why people engage in one rather than the other.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |